Sacred Returns Sacred Returns
i
Mircea Eliade. In 1985 he lost his precious book collection in a fire; it has been speculated that the fire was caused by hot pipe ash. Photo by Louis Monier/Gamma-Rapho via Getty Images
Dreams and Visions

Sacred Returns

On the Universality of Rituals
Tomasz Wiśniewski
Reading
time 12 minutes

These days, celebrating a festival may resemble more a theatrical spectacle rather than an event where something really happens. Mircea Eliade proposed a theory that allows us to understand both the meaning of a religious ritual and a certain universal tendency of the human mind.

Eliade was the best known and perhaps greatest historian of religion in the 20th century. Not only did he author pioneering and still relevant monographs dedicated to phenomena such as shamanism and yoga; he also left behind countless ideas that make it possible to interpret various religious and cultural phenomena. A particular place in the research of the Romanian scholar is occupied by the idea of “crisis and renewal,” related to his concept of the religious festival.

To understand it, Eliade’s theory of myth must first be summarized. Today, “myth” is a popular word to describe a stereotype or fairy tale, often in relation to Greek and Roman stories. Treating a myth as fabrication or fiction is the long legacy of ancient philosophy. The Milesians subjected the Homeric tales to criticism, providing the beginning of philosophical speculation (contrary to the ethnocentric imagination that’s still so popular today, this contribution did not come exclusively from the Greeks; philosophy emerged in a similar way in China, India, and Mesoamerica). But that doesn’t mean these first philosophers didn’t think with the help of myths themselves; more fantasies emerged in place of traditional ideas. According to Eliade, mythical thinking is typical for all of humanity. French anthropologist Claude Lévi-Strauss said the same thing, though from a slightly different perspective. For example, he believed the theory of the Big Bang or Schrödinger’s cat were new variations on mythical structures known to ethnologists and historians—the Big Bang is fundamentally very reminiscent of the Biblical myth of creation ex nihilo.

But ethnology and religious studies don’t use the concept of myth as a synonym for “fabrication.” From a religious person’s

Information

You’ve reached your free article’s limit this month. You can get unlimited access to all our articles and audio content with our digital subscription. If you have an active subscription, please log in.

Subscribe

Also read:

In Death There Is Also Life In Death There Is Also Life
i
Vinciane Despret. ©Ajuntament de Barcelona, CCCB. Miquel Taverna, 2020
Dreams and Visions

In Death There Is Also Life

An Interview with Vinciane Despret
Paulina Małochleb

Cultivating relationships with the dead not only brings people comfort in the midst of grief, but also restores meaning to life. Vinciane Despret, a Belgian researcher and the author of Our Grateful Dead: Stories of Those Left Behind, talks about the profession of midwifery for the dead and the benefits of returning to home funerals.

Paulina Małochleb: What is a death midwife?

Continue reading