The Reluctant Mr. Darwin and His Dangerous Idea
i
Charles Darwin, ca. 1880. Photo by Heritage Image Partnership Ltd/Alamy Stock Photo
Science

The Reluctant Mr. Darwin and His Dangerous Idea

On the Origin of the Theory
Mikołaj Golachowski
Reading
time 18 minutes

In order to try to briefly describe the story of Charles Darwin and his revolutionary theory we could use five words: chance, restraint, ingenuity, practicality and diligence . . .

When HMS Beagle finally left the British port of Plymouth on December 27, 1831, no one had any idea that the fate of humanity had taken a turn, and that our species would soon embark on the most fascinating, instructivem and consequential journey in its intellectual history.

A Chance Trip in Spite of His Nose

Charles Robert Darwin was certainly not thinking about that when, thanks to some acquaintances, the young graduate, who was just shy of his 23rd birthday, was hired as a geologist and gentleman on the crew of the Beagle. Captain Robert FitzRoy took him aboard principally in order to have an intelligent person to talk to during the three-year research voyage. They were already one month late in departing, chiefly because of the raging December storms, but also because they had lost at least one day to Christmas drunkenness.

Darwin was unaware that he had very nearly not been selected for the trip. FitzRoy was a great admirer of the then-very fashionable idea of phrenology, which looked for links between the shape and size of the cranium as a supposed indication of character and mental abilities. During their first meeting, FitzRoy wanted to reject him for his “strange nose,” which allegedly indicated no great intellect, nor the required determination. However, during that first discussion, he changed his mind and, on that occasion at least, the pseudo-scientific theory didn’t get in the way of true science. Both earlier and, surprisingly, nearly two hundred years later, this often happened.

Darwin was young and bright with a Cambridge education, and he came from a very good family with a long tradition of intellectual pursuits. His father was a famous doctor and his grandfather, Erasmus, a famous geologist (in addition to his well-deserved infamy as a womanizer and reveller). Against the wishes of his parents, Charles gave up his medical studies, later completing a standard bachelor’s degree (including a course in geology), but rather than studying, he preferred gentlemanly pursuits, such as horse riding, shooting birds and collecting rare beetles. He was always interested in the natural world and read widely on the subject, but, as he himself later claimed, during this time he derived more pleasure from Shakespeare, Milton, and Byron, as well as a number of other poets. However, he was certainly honest, methodical, and inquisitive. On the expedition, he was supposed to concentrate on geology and collect as many specimens as possible, including

Information

You’ve reached your free article’s limit this month. You can get unlimited access to all our articles and audio content with our digital subscription. If you have an active subscription, please log in.

Subscribe

Also read:

Earthworms on the Piano
i
Charles Darwin, 1881
Science

Earthworms on the Piano

On the Legacy of Charles Darwin
Aleksandra Gosk, Tomasz Sitarz

The creator of the theory of evolution believed that even though the constant fight for survival is a given in nature, our sense of kindness and beauty comes directly from animals, says cultural scientist and philosopher Justyna Schollenberger.

Aleksandra Gosk: If biology is a story about nature, Charles Darwin was the one to make humans part of its narrative. But who were our heroes (and those of Darwin) before the theory of evolution came along?

Continue reading